TTMUA Lab
TMUA 2023 · Paper 2 · Question 7 of 20

TMUA 2023 Paper 2 Question 7

Coordinate geometry — Straight lines · necessary but not sufficient. Try it first; the answer and a full worked solution are below.

TMUA 2023 · Paper 2Coordinate geometryStraight lines · necessary but not sufficient6 options
The graph of the line ax + by = c is drawn, where a, b and c are real non-zero constants.

Which one of the following is a necessary but not sufficient condition for the line to have a positive gradient and a positive y-intercept?

  1. Acb > 0 and ab < 0
  2. Bcb < 0 and ab > 0
  3. Ca > b > c
  4. Da < b < c
  5. Ea and c have opposite signs
  6. Fa and c have the same sign
Show the answer and worked solution
answer · E
  1. Acb > 0 and ab < 0
  2. Bcb < 0 and ab > 0
  3. Ca > b > c
  4. Da < b < c
  5. Ea and c have opposite signs
  6. Fa and c have the same sign
Rearranged, the line is y = −abx + cb, so a positive gradient means ab < 0 and a positive intercept means cb > 0. Together those say a and b have opposite signs while c and b share a sign — so a and c have opposite signs, making that condition necessary. It is not sufficient: a = 1, b = 1, c = −1 has a and c opposite in sign but gives gradient −1. (The first option is the full condition, so it is sufficient too.)